If your cat only eats one thing:
Cat owner fed her fussy cat the same can for six years. Then she read three words on the back of it.
AND: The 5 kitchen hacks she tried to put back what that can was missing, ranked worst to best. Four of them fell short. Her cat never noticed the one that won, and the bowl came back licked clean the first night.
I'm Joanne, from Tucson, Arizona. I've fed my cat Pickle the same can of food for six years. One night I turned it around and read the back. Here's what I found, and what I did about it.
Pickle has been fussy since the day I brought her home.
She was a tiny tabby from the shelter, and she turned her nose up at her very first bowl. She still does.
I've tried every food in the pet store. Pate, chunks, shreds, gravy, the fancy cans and the cheap ones. If she doesn't like it, she won't eat it. Not that night, and not the next morning either. She sits by the bowl and waits me out.
And I always cave.
An owner on a cat forum described my life better than I ever could:
"Give her food she doesn't like, and she'll happily just leave it untouched for a day or more, seemingly unphased, until I cave in, and give her one of the two things she DOES eat"
For Pickle there is only one thing she'll eat as a meal. Applaws Tuna Fillet in Broth. She eats it every single time. So for six years, that's what she's had.
I know what people say. Fed is best, and I agree. Another owner put it the way I always did:
"It might not be ideal, but it's better she's eating something than nothing"
Pickle looked fine. Bright eyes, a decent coat, still chasing her string toy at night. One owner on a forum wrote the exact thing I told myself:
"She’s healthy and doing great, so I can only assume it’s okay."
Then one night in March, I was opening one more can of the same tuna, and for no reason at all, I turned it around.
Three words, in small print on the back.
Supplemental feeding only.
I'm going to show you what those three words mean, why your cat's one food might carry them too, and the 5 kitchen hacks I tried to make up for it, ranked worst to best. Four of them fell short.
The fifth one, she never noticed.
The three words on the back of the can

The full line says: This product is intended for intermittent or supplemental feeding only.
In six years I'd never once read it. Applaws is a good brand. I paid more for it than for the cans on the bottom shelf, and I guess I thought more money meant more complete.
That night I looked it up.
The wording comes from AAFCO, the group that sets the rules for what goes on a pet food label in the US. A food that says complete and balanced has everything a cat needs to live on it. A food that says supplemental feeding only doesn't. It's a side dish.
And the example AAFCO gives on its own website? A can of tuna sold for cats.
Then I went to the forums, and I found out I wasn't the only one who'd missed it.
"I'm a month in to it just now realizing it's meant to be supplemental."
An owner whose cat only eats tuna:
"I recently heard that, while tuna is fine for cat food, tuna doesn't contain the right nutrients to be the ONLY food a cat eats"
And the one that made me sit down on the kitchen floor:
"If I hadn’t paid attention I probably would’ve kept feeding my cat Applaws thinking I was doing right by her."
That was me. For six years.
The Small-Print Trap: why the one food she'll eat is the one food that never had to be complete
Nobody explained this part to me, so I'll keep it simple.
Cats can't make enough taurine on their own. Dogs can. People can. Cats can't. It has to come from what they eat, every day.
Taurine is what a cat's heart and eyes run on. Back in the 1970s and 80s, cats on early commercial foods started going blind, and then their hearts started failing. The cause turned out to be too little taurine. After that, every complete cat food had to carry enough of it.
So when a cat eats a complete food, taurine is taken care of. That part works.
But a fussy cat doesn't eat a complete food. She eats one thing. And very often, that one thing is a food that never had to be complete. A supplemental can like Pickle's. Plain chicken. Tuna. Treats. Or just the gravy off the top.
The pickier she gets, the further her bowl gets from the foods that have taurine added.
I call it the Small-Print Trap.
Think of it as a side dish served as dinner every night. The side dish isn't bad. It was just never meant to be the whole meal.
The forums put it more bluntly than I would:
"if your cat doesn't get taurine then it can/may be likely to go blind and develop heart problems."
I want to be clear, because I've seen those scary ads too. This isn't about all cat food. Complete foods have taurine. This is only about the one thing a fussy cat eats instead.
Why "she looks fine" stopped making me feel better
Pickle looked fine. That was the trap.
Nothing on the outside tells you her bowl is short on taurine. There's no warning. You find out late, or you find out from a label at midnight, like I did.
And I couldn't just switch her. One owner wrote the sentence I'd been living:
"I can't see any way to FORCE her to eat other foods."
So I didn't switch her. I went into the kitchen and tried to make up for it.
Over the next few months I tried five different hacks. And I scored every one of them on three simple questions:
1. Will she actually eat it? In her one food, without sniffing and walking away.
2. Does it put back taurine? The one nutrient cats can't make enough of.
3. Is it a known amount, every day? Not “some”. A number.
Only one passed all three.
Here's every hack I tried, ranked worst to best.
The 5 kitchen hacks for a cat who'll only eat one thing, ranked worst to best
Switching her to a complete food

(The textbook answer. But a fussy cat will outlast you.) Every forum says it first, and they're right that it would close the gap. I bought three complete foods that people swore by. Pickle sniffed each bowl and walked off. By day two, I was the one who broke.
The problem: a fussy cat can wait longer than you can. One owner wrote:
"One of them dropped almost a full kilogram in weight just by pulling a hunger strike when I tried giving them something better for them."
A food she won't eat closes nothing. #1 keeps the food she already loves. The next one gets closer...
A nutrient paste, oil or powder stirred into her food

(The right idea, in a form she can smell.) This is where most of us end up. Keep her food, and add what's missing. I bought a vitamin paste from the pet store and stirred a little into her Applaws. She took one sniff and left the whole bowl.
I'm not the only one.
"I've tried adding water and nutrient paste to patè canned foods but she can't be fooled."
"They also hate any of the added extras I put like Churus, collagen powder, quail yolks, salmon oil."
Even the "completer" powders raw feeders mix into meat have the same problem. You have to weigh the meat to get the dose right:
"knowing the exact amount of the completer to add is crucial for a cat's health"
The problem: a paste or a powder has a smell and a grit that a fussy cat will find. And it can cost you more than one meal:
"Since your cat seems to be picky, doing anything to change up the fancy feast gravy lovers might then cause an aversion to it no matter what you do or don't do to it in the future."
Lose the one food, and you've lost everything. #1 goes in with no smell and no grit. The next one feels like real food...
Boiled chicken on the side

(Real meat, and she wolfs it. But the taurine ends up in the water.) Pickle will eat boiled chicken. Not instead of her can, but a few shreds next to it. It felt like the most loving thing I did all week. Real meat, plain water, nothing added.
The problem: plain chicken isn't a complete food either. As one owner was told:
"Nope, chicken breast is not nutritionally complete. Is is lacking in taurine, calcium, phosphorous, and a whole lot of other vitamins/minerals essential for cat health."
And boiling makes it worse, because taurine dissolves in water. In one owner's words:
"boiling chicken the taurine goes from the chicken into the water used to boil it."
I'd been pouring that water down the sink every single time. #1 puts back what the pot takes out. The next one is the runner-up...
Boiled chicken hearts

(The richest natural source of taurine. But nobody can tell you how much she got.) Spend any time on the cat forums and someone will tell you to buy chicken hearts. They're right. Hearts are one of the richest natural sources of taurine there is, and they're cheap. Pickle would eat half of one if I chopped it small and set it next to her tuna.
The problem: I couldn't answer one question. How many milligrams did she get today?
The hearts sat in boiling water, and the taurine leaves the meat for the water. Heat breaks some of it down. No two hearts are the same. And some nights she ate half, some nights she ate none.
“Some” is not a number. A cat needs taurine every day, not some days. #1 gives her a known 100 mg, in one dropper she never notices.
So what took the #1 spot?
Four hacks. One she wouldn't eat. One she caught, so it gave her nothing. Two gave her some taurine, but I could never know how much. None of them put back a known amount of taurine in a way Pickle couldn't catch.
The answer came from the forums again, from owners who have to get something into a cat that refuses it every day. They keep the food the cat will eat and mix in what's missing. Their trick is to start tiny:
"starting with a teeny tiny pinch to minimize the chance of the cat detecting anything different"
That was it. Keep her food. Start tiny.
But a pinch of powder still has grit and a smell. I'd even read a review of a taurine powder from an owner whose cats beat it:
"I'm just saying my cats are too picky and I don't think they are eating enough to get benefit from the taurine powder."
A dose she doesn't eat isn't a dose. I needed something with no grit and no smell at all.
PawFectHeaven Liquid Taurine is a flavorless, odorless liquid with a marked dropper. There's 100 mg of taurine in every 1 mL dropper. One dropper a day for a cat up to 10 lbs, and two for a bigger cat. It mixes into wet or dry food, and it goes straight into the gravy or the broth, which is the part fussy cats love most. There's nothing for her to find. It just disappears into the food she already eats. (30-day money-back guarantee)
It doesn't turn her can into a complete food, and I won't pretend it does. It puts back the one nutrient that matters most, the one cats can't make enough of, without a fight.

Here's how I brought it in:
Night 1: Just a few drops in the broth of her Applaws, a tiny part of a full dose, so there was nothing new for her to notice. I stood in the kitchen doorway and watched. She ate the lot.
Nights 2 to 6: A few more drops each night, working up to a full dropper. Still nothing. No sniff test, no walking off.
Week 2: The full dropper, every night, in the same can she's eaten for six years. She has never once walked away from it.
Pickle doesn't know anything changed. That's the whole point. Her bowl comes back licked clean, same as always.
The only difference is me. I don't have to assume it's okay anymore. I know she gets the one thing her food was missing, a known amount, every day.
A complete food would fix it, if she'd eat it. Pickle wouldn't touch it, so for her it did nothing.
| Will she eat it? | Puts back taurine? | A known amount, every day? | |
|---|---|---|---|
| #5 A complete food | ✗ | ✓ | ✓ |
| #4 Paste or powder | ✗ | Some | ✗ |
| #3 Boiled chicken | ✓ | A little | ✗ |
| #2 Boiled hearts | Some nights | ✓ | ✗ |
| #1 PawFectHeaven drops | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
If your cat will only eat one thing, turn the can around tonight. If it says supplemental, or if her one thing is plain chicken, tuna or treats, her bowl has the same gap Pickle's had. You don't have to change her food or win a fight.
It wasn't just Pickle

“Mine is the fussiest cat alive. She caught the paste, she caught the powder, she even caught a pill inside a treat. I started with a few drops of this in her gravy and she licked the bowl clean. Three weeks in and she has never once walked away.”Denise K., Ohio
“Everyone online kept telling me her food was already complete. Then I actually read the can. Supplemental. I felt sick. Now I just add the dropper to the same food she's always eaten.”Marissa T., Texas
“I was nervous about buying taurine online, there's so much sketchy stuff out there. This has the mg right on the label and it doesn't smell of anything. I sniffed it myself before I gave it to her.”Carol B., Ontario
“I've thrown away more cat food than I want to admit, so I nearly didn't try this. The money-back promise is what got me over the line. I never needed it.”Linda P., Queensland
Keep the food she loves, and put back the one thing it's missing.
Why I trust what's in the bottle
- 98.5% pure free-form taurine, pharmaceutical grade, in a liquid base that's listed in full on the box.
- A 60 mL bottle, 100 mg in every 1 mL, marked on the dropper and printed on the label.
- No smell, no taste. It mixes into wet or dry food.
- Safe every day, including for cats with kidney issues and cats on medication.
- One bottle lasts two months for a cat under 10 lbs (cats over 10 lbs get two droppers a day).
- Made by a UK company and shipped direct from its manufacturing partner's warehouse.
Keep the one food she loves, or get every penny back

I once added up what I'd spent on food Pickle refused over six years. It was more than ten bottles of this. I know I'm not the only one:
"I’ve spent so much money trying different wet foods and treats, but they refuse to eat anything else consistently."
You're covered by a 30-day money-back guarantee. If your cat won't touch it, you get a full refund, even on a half-empty bottle.
So you've got two paths. You can keep turning the can around and telling yourself it's probably okay. Or you can put back the one thing it's missing tonight, a few drops at a time, and know.
P.S. Pickle is asleep on the windowsill as I write this, next to an empty Applaws can. Same cat. Same can. The only thing that changed is one dropper a day of the one thing her bowl was missing.